E aqui está a lista completa dos troféus/conquistas do FIFA 16. Esta lista foi retirada do Xbox One, mas não deverá ter mudanças em relação à versão para PS4, PS3 ou Xbox 360. São 44 troféus que somados resultam em 1000 pontos. Há ainda 3 conquistas relacionadas ao futebol feminino, novidade para esta edição. Confira a lista completa (em inglês):
 | Can't Touch This (15) Beat an opposing player using no touch dribbling |
 | Threading the needle (15) Assist a goal using a driven ground pass |
 | Take Aim (30) Have 100% shot accuracy in a match (10 shots minimum) |
 | I am the boss (15) Substitute your star player in a match (highest rated player in the team) |
 | I brought the ball (15) Have more than 65% possession in a match |
 | Fair Play (15) Finish a match without conceding a foul against you (offsides do not count) |
 | Around the wall (15) Score a goal with a curled shot from a free kick |
 | Set-piece specialist (15) Score 2 goals from a corner in a match |
 | It's a lottery (15) Win a penalty shoot-out |
 | Go for it! (15) During open play, score a long-distance goal with a defender (25 yards out) |
 | Half-Time pep-talk (15) Win a match against the Legendary CPU after being down at half-time |
 | The Invincibles (80) Win all 4 matches in an Online Draft Mode session in FIFA Ultimate Team |
 | Testing the Waters (15) Win all 4 matches in a Single Player Draft Mode session in FIFA Ultimate Team |
 | Legacy in the making (30) First appearance of a player bought from the Transfer Market in Ultimate Team |
 | FUT 50 (105) Have a player score their 50th goal at the club in FIFA Ultimate Team |
 | No hard feelings, right? (15) Win a Friendly Season in FIFA Ultimate Team |
 | Trial offer (15) Sign a Loan Player from the EASFC Catalogue |
 | A loyal ally is hard to find (15) Buy a player from the FUT Transfer Market and earn his loyalty by playing 10 or more games with him |
 | Molded to perfection (15) Apply your first Chemistry Style consumable in FUT |
 | Trial of Power (15) Challenge and complete a match against the Team of the Week in FUT |
 | Class of '16 (15) Win a division title in FUT Seasons |
 | Mutiny! (15) Change your captain in FUT |
 | Adding some context (15) Play a full match with the "FIFA Trainer" overlays turned on |
 | Dream-team in progress (30) Sign a world class player in manager Career mode (80+ rated) |
 | Going up? (25) Earn a Promotion in Seasons |
 | Friendship test (15) Finish an Online Friendlies Season |
 | Social craving (15) Share an EA SPORTS Football Club Activity |
 | Giving back (15) Gift an EA SPORTS Football Club Catalogue item |
 | All for myself (15) Purchase an EA SPORTS Football Club Catalogue item |
 | We’re in the game! (15) Play a women's football match |
 | New Silverware (25) Win the Women's International Cup tournament |
 | 5 Star performance (15) Score 5 goals in a women's football match |
 | I got this! (15) Perform a slide tackle and keep possession of the ball in a women's football match |
 | Got flair? (15) Score a goal with Flair Shot in a women's football match |
 | You Struck Gold! (25) Scout and find a player with any combination of 3 GTN player attributes |
 | Management at its best (50) Win a Trophy as a Team manager |
 | From zero to hero (30) Get your Play as Player to be featured in the Team of the Week |
 | Baby steps (15) Complete all Drills in FIFA Basics |
 | Quiz completed (15) Fill up all Team Sheets slots |
 | Start the quiz (15) Create a New Team Sheet |
 | Gold acquisition (15) Buy a player which is in a league above you |
 | Never quit (30) Play a consecutive match in Seasons |
 | Just for inspiration (15) Copy a Squad from the end of an online match in FIFA Ultimate Team |
 | Play Beautiful (60) Score a goal after 10 consecutive passes in the opposing third of the pitch |